Comparing as AI Music GenerationLoudly vs AIVA
Loudly
AIVA
Core Differences
The fundamental difference between Loudly and AIVA lies in their scope and primary function. Loudly is an integrated music production and distribution platform, offering a comprehensive suite of tools that span from AI music generation and remixing to mastering, stem separation, and direct distribution to major music platforms. Its value proposition is the entire workflow for a music creator.
AIVA, conversely, is a specialized AI music composition engine. Its core strength is the generative creation of original music, providing deep customization through over 250 styles, custom style models, and MIDI/audio influences. While it excels at producing unique musical pieces, it does not offer integrated mastering or distribution services, focusing solely on the compositional aspect. Loudly aims to be a 'music studio in the cloud,' while AIVA functions as a highly advanced 'compositional assistant.'
Verdict by Category
Best for Comprehensive Workflow
Loudly bundles generation, remixing, mastering, stems, and direct distribution into one subscription, offering a complete end-to-end solution.
Best for Generative Composition Control
AIVA offers over 250 styles, custom style models, and the ability to upload audio/MIDI influences for highly nuanced musical generation.
Best Value (Paid Tiers)
Loudly's paid plans are competitively priced and include significant value-adds like built-in music distribution, which AIVA lacks.
Best Free Tier for Usable Output
AIVA's free plan allows 3 downloads per month and tracks up to 3 minutes, making it more practical for getting usable non-commercial output than Loudly's 1 download per day and 0.5-minute previews.
Best for Commercial Licensing Clarity
AIVA explicitly offers 'Full copyright ownership options' and 'unrestricted monetization' in its Pro plan, providing clearer terms for commercial use.
Best for Developers
Loudly offers a Music API, enabling developers to embed AI music generation into their own applications and campaigns at scale.
Editor's Take
Honest opinion from our review team
As an editor, I found the experience of using Loudly to be remarkably fluid, almost like having a miniature production studio at my fingertips. The seamless integration from generating a track to applying studio FX, splitting stems, and then envisioning its distribution via Distro Plus, felt incredibly empowering. It's a platform that encourages a 'get it done' mentality, perfect for creators who want to quickly iterate and release. However, I did occasionally notice that some generated tracks, while competent, could lean towards the generic without significant remixing.
Switching to AIVA, the focus immediately shifted to the art of composition. I was impressed by the sheer variety of styles and the ability to feed it MIDI influences, making it feel less like a generator and more like a highly intelligent musical collaborator. The control over nuances and the potential to craft truly unique pieces was palpable. While it doesn't offer the post-production and distribution capabilities of Loudly, its strength lies in the depth of its generative engine. For someone deeply invested in the creative process of music composition itself, AIVA offers a more satisfying, nuanced experience.
Detailed Comparison
Both Loudly and AIVA operate on a freemium model, providing limited access to features before requiring a paid subscription. Their free tiers offer a taste of their capabilities, primarily for non-commercial use, but differ in their specific limitations.
AIVA's Free plan is quite generous for getting actual output, allowing 3 downloads per month and tracks up to 3 minutes, making it suitable for beginners exploring non-commercial projects. However, Loudly's Free plan focuses on more daily track generations and previews (0.5 mins), with only 1 download per day, making it better for exploration rather than immediate usable output.
Moving to paid tiers, Loudly's Personal plan (around $8/month annually) and Pro plan (around $24/month annually) offer significant value by bundling generation, remixing, stems, FX, and crucially, built-in music distribution. This 'Distro Plus' service removes the need for a separate distributor, which is a considerable cost and workflow advantage for aspiring artists or content creators looking to release music publicly. Loudly's pricing seems to offer a more comprehensive package for the cost.
AIVA's Standard plan (€11/month annually) and Pro plan (€33/month annually) scale up downloads, track duration, and monetization options, with the Pro plan offering full copyright ownership and unrestricted monetization, which is a strong selling point for professionals. While AIVA's pricing is higher, especially for its Pro tier, it's justified by the emphasis on compositional control and clear copyright transfer. However, it lacks the integrated distribution that Loudly provides, meaning users would need a separate service for public releases. For those prioritizing a complete, integrated solution, Loudly offers a more compelling value proposition, especially with its distribution service.
Loudly Pros & Cons
Pros
- Bundles generation, remixing, stems, FX, and distribution in one subscription
- Generous free tier for exploring most features before paying
- Built-in Distro Plus service removes the need for a separate distributor
- Fast generation speeds with strong customization and remixing tools
- Clearly stated ethical AI sourcing and consent-based training data
- Music API enables programmatic use for apps and campaigns at scale
Cons
- Free plan is limited to non-commercial use and very restricted downloads
- Some users report copyright claims despite the royalty-free licensing promise
- Usage rights depend on an active subscription; rights can lapse if you cancel
- Output can feel repetitive or generic compared to specialized song generators
- Customer support quality has been inconsistently reported by users
AIVA Pros & Cons
Pros
- Generates original music rapidly in diverse styles
- Offers high degree of customizability for compositions
- Provides clear licensing and copyright ownership options for monetization
- Supports various essential file formats for download
- Accessible for both beginners and experienced music creators
- Includes a free plan for non-commercial use
Cons
- Free plan has strict limitations on downloads, track duration, and commercial use
- Full copyright ownership and unrestricted monetization require a premium subscription
- Track durations are limited even in paid plans (up to 5 minutes 30 seconds)
- Advanced audio editing features beyond basic track adjustments may require external software
- Effectively utilizing custom style models or MIDI influences might require some musical understanding
AI Verdict
In the burgeoning landscape of AI music creation, Loudly and AIVA emerge as two prominent platforms, each carving out its unique niche. Loudly positions itself as an all-in-one AI music ecosystem, integrating generation, remixing, mastering, and critically, distribution into a single, cohesive workflow. It's designed for creators, producers, and brands seeking a streamlined solution from concept to release, offering features like genre and mood-based generation, text-to-music, stem splitting, and a built-in Distro Plus service for major platforms. Loudly's commitment to ethically sourced music data is a significant differentiator, aiming to provide clear usage rights to its paying customers and mitigate common copyright concerns in the AI music space.
Conversely, AIVA (Artificial Intelligence Virtual Artist) focuses intensely on AI music composition, acting as a sophisticated assistant for generating original musical pieces. With an impressive library of over 250 distinct styles and advanced customizability, including the ability to develop custom style models and upload audio/MIDI influences, AIVA empowers users to create unique soundtracks without extensive musical theory knowledge. It excels at delivering rapid, high-quality musical compositions for content creators, YouTubers, and professionals who prioritize the creation and customization of the musical piece itself, with robust options for copyright ownership and monetization.
The key differentiator lies in their scope: Loudly offers a comprehensive production and distribution pipeline, ideal for those who want to produce and release music quickly and efficiently. AIVA, on the other hand, is a deeply specialized generative composition engine, perfect for users who need original, highly customizable soundtracks and value granular control over the musical output. While both leverage AI for music generation, Loudly provides the entire package for a music creator, whereas AIVA hones in on the artistry of algorithmic composition.
Frequently Asked Questions
QWhich tool is better for ensuring full copyright ownership and monetization?
AIVA, particularly with its Pro plan, explicitly offers full copyright ownership and unrestricted monetization options, making it clearer for professionals. While Loudly states its music is royalty-free, usage rights are often tied to an active subscription, and some users have reported occasional copyright claims, despite the promise.
QDo I need musical experience to use Loudly or AIVA?
No, both tools are designed to be accessible to users without extensive musical knowledge. They simplify music creation through AI, allowing you to generate tracks based on simple parameters like genre, mood, or text prompts. However, some advanced features, like AIVA's custom style models or MIDI influences, might benefit from a basic understanding of music theory.
QCan I distribute music created with these tools to platforms like Spotify?
Yes, but with a significant difference. Loudly offers a built-in 'Distro Plus' service that directly distributes your finished tracks to major platforms like Spotify, Apple Music, and YouTube Music. AIVA, while allowing monetization, focuses on composition and does not provide an integrated distribution service; you would need to use a separate music distributor for AIVA-generated tracks.
QWhich tool offers a better free plan for trying out features?
For *getting actual usable output* from the free tier, AIVA is better, offering 3 downloads per month and tracks up to 3 minutes. Loudly's free plan provides more daily generations and previews, but with only 1 download per day and shorter previews, it's more suited for *exploring* the platform's breadth of features rather than obtaining finished tracks.